Higher rent vs lower rent
Click here for Top Ten Discussions. CLICK HERE for Q & A Homepage
Receive Free Rental Owner Updates Email:  
MrLandlord Q & A
     
     
Higher rent vs lower rent (by Sirduke731 [MD]) May 28, 2026 8:00 PM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by NE [PA]) May 28, 2026 8:03 PM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by Ray-N-Pa [PA]) May 28, 2026 8:33 PM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by Deanna [TX]) May 28, 2026 9:27 PM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by Deanna [TX]) May 28, 2026 9:28 PM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by plenty [MO]) May 28, 2026 9:56 PM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by Robert J [CA]) May 28, 2026 11:19 PM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by Bonanza [NC]) May 29, 2026 6:10 AM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by Paulio [PA]) May 29, 2026 8:06 AM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by zero [IN]) May 29, 2026 9:33 AM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by plenty [MO]) May 29, 2026 9:51 AM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by mapleaf18 [NY]) May 29, 2026 9:53 AM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by Sirduke731 [MD]) May 29, 2026 2:25 PM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by Pmh [TX]) May 29, 2026 2:53 PM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by SirDuke731 [MD]) May 29, 2026 6:12 PM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by JS [CA]) May 29, 2026 6:33 PM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by MikeA [TX]) May 29, 2026 11:57 PM
       Higher rent vs lower rent (by Pmh [TX]) May 30, 2026 6:37 PM

Click here to reply to this discussion.
Click Here to send this discussion to a friend

Higher rent vs lower rent (by Sirduke731 [MD]) Posted on: May 28, 2026 8:00 PM
Message:

Hi all.

My question is what would one rather have? Advertising a property at a higher rent and getting fewer applications or lower rent and getting more applications?

I have a property where the average market rents are $1,500 but I advertised it for $1,700. It's in a B area, is a large single-family with 3bed/2 baths and a finished basement with a washer, no dryer. It's about a mile from a university and across the street from a public golf course.

I've received 6 leads with one showing serious interest.

Just wanted some suggestions. --68.134.xx.xxx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by NE [PA]) Posted on: May 28, 2026 8:03 PM
Message:

Higher rent time and time again gets me more knuckleheads who think they should get a place just because they want it. It doesn’t slow down the applications coming in. Lower rent still gets me a fair share of knuckleheads, but it also gets me money conscious tenants. I have better luck under pricing a unit to get it rented and raising the rent over the next couple years. --24.152.xxx.xx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by Ray-N-Pa [PA]) Posted on: May 28, 2026 8:33 PM
Message:

Market rent is market rent.

Advertise it as ....Now LEASING Starting at $1,500 Call - --173.188.xx.xx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by Deanna [TX]) Posted on: May 28, 2026 9:27 PM
Message:

A lot comes down to the other available options at your price point.

People who have a certain level of economic security have choice. They might choose yours because it has (location) (amenities) (charm) in its favor. Or they might bypass yours, because their rental dollars can stretch further with another option.

In your case, it will probably work out, because one of the factors in play will probably appeal to them over the other competition at your price point. But if you take it too far, or if you try to play that card from a weak hand, results will be different. --172.58.xxx.xxx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by Deanna [TX]) Posted on: May 28, 2026 9:28 PM
Message:

But ultimately, a lot hinges on whether you're offering something that's more valuable to them than keeping the extra $200/month you're asking. --172.58.xxx.xxx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by plenty [MO]) Posted on: May 28, 2026 9:56 PM
Message:

Neither is working for me. --172.59.xxx.xx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by Robert J [CA]) Posted on: May 28, 2026 11:19 PM
Message:

When I list a rental at a "discounted" lower price, I get applicants that can barely afford that price--with only a 2.5x income to rent level instead or 3.0. When I raise the price to "more than market" I reach people with college degrees working skilled jobs with savings -- that can easily afford the higher rent.

However, the property next door knocked down and built high end units. Rent ranging from $3750 to $5500 per unit (1,2 and 3 bedrooms). My building had a 1 and 2 bedroom vacancy. I didn't put out a sign. When I saw those leaving next door with a disgust on there faces at the double the market price, I asked if they wanted to see my units. Those entitled applicants judged my rentals by the outside of the building. But when they went inside, my units did compare with newer ones .So instead of asking $2350 for my 2 bedroom, I started at 2,750. I got offers for $2,500 er month. I got 6 months up front and a good tenant. --47.155.xx.xxx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by Bonanza [NC]) Posted on: May 29, 2026 6:10 AM
Message:

It sounds like you have a nicer than average home so you should get a nicer than average price.

I find at the higher rent mark there are less applicants but also less unqualified applications.

If $1500 is your average base and your place has all those aforementioned features I might start at $1595 with the thought of hitting the 1600s the following year at lease renewal.

I actually find a large house harder to rent than a smaller one. You'd think people would want the space.

Best of luck with getting a tenant.

--66.153.xxx.xxx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by Paulio [PA]) Posted on: May 29, 2026 8:06 AM
Message:

Aside from getting a place rented, I need to feel good about doing it. If I rent a place at a deliberately low rent, it usually aggravates me when I get a complaint or even a basic request from the tenant. I think, "You're getting this place for a discounted rent and you have the nerve to complain that you feel a draft through the window???" I don't want to feel angry when I hear from a tenant. Market rent tends to alleviate that. I think, "Well, at least I'm getting good rent." It makes a difference to me. --50.32.xx.xxx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by zero [IN]) Posted on: May 29, 2026 9:33 AM
Message:

Fix the drafty window and charge what you want.

But I understand what you are saying.

My rents typically hover around or a little under market. If I had a tenant that complained because I didn't provide something like a dishwasher I would kindly remind then that it didn't exist when they rented the place and I will not be adding it.

I have been slowly increasing my places to closer market. The problem is that there are some places that are charging well over what I would consider a fair rent. I do not want to fall in that hole. Charge too much and the tenant feels entitled, or you get no tenant at all because the cost is more than they can comfortably afford. --47.227.xx.xxx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by plenty [MO]) Posted on: May 29, 2026 9:51 AM
Message:

Doesn't matter the cost they will pay for what they want. They all bring their entitlement attitude. --172.59.xxx.xxx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by mapleaf18 [NY]) Posted on: May 29, 2026 9:53 AM
Message:

What plenty said. Entitlement is off the charts since C19. --72.0.xxx.xx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by Sirduke731 [MD]) Posted on: May 29, 2026 2:25 PM
Message:

These are all great suggestions. Thank you. Just to be clear, the rentals listed at $1,500 is a number my lender came back with when they ran rental comps when the did the loan. Those are for properties that are 2/1 at 890-1025 sq ft. My property is 3/2 at 2000 sq ft in a B area. When I checked Zillow and rentometer they came back with 1890 - 2000 and when I checked Redfin for available properties with my specs, I found listings between 1900-2200.

I plan on doing what a few posters mentioned, lower the rent to get it rented and raising the rent annually.

Thanks again. --99.58.xx.xx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by Pmh [TX]) Posted on: May 29, 2026 2:53 PM
Message:

add the dryer. does it have a fenced yard ? do you not accept smokers. I have houses in a two university town. my houses are non smoking. A huge niche mkt. I provide appliances. students don’t want to mess with buying them. I allow pets. just about all the rentals in town do not allow. another niche. keep your rents higher than “comps” I do. I don’t want a lot of applicants. I want applicants who see my rents, see the amenities and will pay. --146.75.xxx.xxx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by SirDuke731 [MD]) Posted on: May 29, 2026 6:12 PM
Message:

Dryer, no. Washer, yes. Fenced backyard, yes. Pets allowed, yes. Smoking allowed, no. I plan to keep it above the lender's comps, but not too high. I don't want it sitting on the market like the other properties I've seen; 20 - 35+ days. It already took roughly 2 months to get it ready to rent. No need to continue letting it sit. A $500 monthly cash flow is better than no cash flow or letting it sit to get another $200, maybe. --68.134.xx.xxx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by JS [CA]) Posted on: May 29, 2026 6:33 PM
Message:

I vote for lower rents given only those two options. The way I price my units is by of course looking at market rents but also looking at response rates. If there is not enough demand I have a hard time choosing a tenant. I find that the least worthy are willing to pay the most.

I also find that lower rents mean that people stay longer. I make more money with low turnover. My idea of a discount is not as wide as your example. --162.204.xxx.xxx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by MikeA [TX]) Posted on: May 29, 2026 11:57 PM
Message:

First off, don't take anyone else's word for what market rent is. The banker has ulterior motives (to make sure you can make the payments, so they guess low). Redfin and Zillow are terrible at comparing properties, they stop at simple sqft calculations and bedroom and bathroom counts. They don't consider things like floorplan flows, how fixed up it is, fenced backyards, curb appeal, and cleanliness. You need to look at your competition and see what they are charging for LIKE properties in the same condition with the same amenities and/or make the $ adjustments so you are comparing apples to apples. That's the only way you are going to have a good basis for market rent. --99.64.xx.xx




Higher rent vs lower rent (by Pmh [TX]) Posted on: May 30, 2026 6:37 PM
Message:

SirDuke: to respond with some suggestions: my houses have all been rented since I bought them, unless I take one out for rehab. All of them have been with 2-3 renters. If one student is leaving (graduated) I offer $100 to each renters if anyone of the remaining renters refers a replacement (that meets criteria) on occasion all will be leaving & I offer the same referral fee and immediate return of their deposits if they leave 3-5 days b4 term expiration so I can turn the house. In 25 years this has always worked. My mkt is students who don’t want to stay after their first year in the dorms (required by the universities. I have also rented to adjunct professors who have their first jobs here. There is a huge mkt for students who are referred by their friends. I make a point of meeting with their parents (who are usually helicopter parents and/or helping their son or daughter move in. Add the dryer (!) all rents do not include utilities. I charge higher rents & they all renew. For the first year they rent from me I require a guarantor. They have no rights to occupy. If rents paid on time I drop the requirement the second & subsequent years. --146.75.xxx.xxx



Click Here to send this discussion to a friend
Report discussion to Webmaster


Reply:
Subject: RE: Higher rent vs lower rent
Your Name:
Your State:

Message:
Higher rent vs lower rent
Would you like to be notified via email when somebody replies to this thread?
If so, you must include your valid email address here. Do not add your address more than once per thread/subject. By entering your email address here, you agree to receive notification from Mrlandlord.com every time anyone replies to "this" thread. You will receive response notifications for up to one week following the original post. Your email address will not be visible to readers.
Email Address: