OT Montana/Bear concerns
Click here for Top Ten Discussions. CLICK HERE for Q & A Homepage
Receive Free Rental Owner Updates Email:  
MrLandlord Q & A
     
     
OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Barbara [VA]) Jul 24, 2021 12:46 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Debbie [NM]) Jul 24, 2021 1:05 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Britt [NC]) Jul 24, 2021 1:32 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Vee [OH]) Jul 24, 2021 1:45 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Robert J [CA]) Jul 24, 2021 3:39 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by hubba huibba [CA]) Jul 24, 2021 5:53 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Barbara [VA]) Jul 24, 2021 8:22 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Barbara [VA]) Jul 24, 2021 8:22 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Barbara [VA]) Jul 24, 2021 8:22 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by hubba huibba [CA]) Jul 24, 2021 8:55 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by P.B. [MI]) Jul 24, 2021 9:02 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Oregon Woodsmoke [ID]) Jul 24, 2021 9:03 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Roy [AL]) Jul 24, 2021 10:47 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Small potatoes [NY]) Jul 25, 2021 12:21 AM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by plenty [MO]) Jul 25, 2021 8:09 AM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by 6x6 [TN]) Jul 25, 2021 11:05 AM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Wilma [PA]) Jul 25, 2021 2:26 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Ltd [AZ]) Jul 25, 2021 6:35 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Ltd [AZ]) Jul 25, 2021 11:28 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by 6x6 [TN]) Jul 26, 2021 1:36 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Barbara [VA]) Jul 26, 2021 9:03 PM
       OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Lana [IN]) Jul 28, 2021 10:33 PM


OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Barbara [VA]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 12:46 PM
Message:

I am getting ready to do a multi day/night canoe/camp trip in Montana with 9 people. They are all in some sorta Bear risk hysteria right now. Are bear attacks a real big concern? My thoughts were stick together, keep food locked up tight and just use common sense. Am I downplaying the risk? I figured it's about the same risk as a shark attack. --174.251.xxx.xx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Debbie [NM]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 1:05 PM
Message:

If you are in a National Park, Rangers usually check and review rules. Last time my brother did a similar trip it was mandatory to carry bear spray and have a bear bag to hang food at camp. Also don't cook where you sleep. Read rules for the NP and you should be fine. --67.211.xx.xxx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Britt [NC]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 1:32 PM
Message:

Yes bears are a real thing in MT. Wolves too. --24.211.xxx.xx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Vee [OH]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 1:45 PM
Message:

Sounds like you might want to camp at Marriott. Autos and trucks can collide with others, planes can bump easier on the ground than in the air - are you dropping into camp from the sky? --76.188.xxx.xxx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Robert J [CA]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 3:39 PM
Message:

I camp at places where I'm allowed to carry protection. Not talking about mosquito repellent.

An Over/Under Shotgun will solve most issues. --47.155.xx.xxx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by hubba huibba [CA]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 5:53 PM
Message:

Just follow the Park Service rules and you'll be fine.

Also, not the smallest amount of food in your car. Not a french fry or candy wrapper. Trust me on this. --157.131.xxx.xx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Barbara [VA]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 8:22 PM
Message:

Hubba hubba I suspect there is a story behind that advice. Would you care to share?

Vee..roflmao, there are 2 people in my group who have dropped by helicopter into remote locations. Everyone in my group has significant outdoor experience. My attitude has been the same as if I was swimming in ocean with the sharks. Figured I had equal chance of shark attack as bear attack. Then they all went paranoid about bear repellent and should we bring a gun and I started second guessing my casual acceptance of possible bears.

Britt, wolves and large cats don't concern me. I can read them (body language). Bears are foreign to me. Suspect would probably give similar cues as to intentions? --174.251.xxx.xx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Barbara [VA]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 8:22 PM
Message:

Hubba hubba I suspect there is a story behind that advice. Would you care to share?

Vee..roflmao, there are 2 people in my group who have dropped by helicopter into remote locations. Everyone in my group has significant outdoor experience. My attitude has been the same as if I was swimming in ocean with the sharks. Figured I had equal chance of shark attack as bear attack. Then they all went paranoid about bear repellent and should we bring a gun and I started second guessing my casual acceptance of possible bears.

Britt, wolves and large cats don't concern me. I can read them (body language). Bears are foreign to me. Suspect would probably give similar cues as to intentions? --174.251.xxx.xx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Barbara [VA]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 8:22 PM
Message:

Hubba hubba I suspect there is a story behind that advice. Would you care to share?

Vee..roflmao, there are 2 people in my group who have dropped by helicopter into remote locations. Everyone in my group has significant outdoor experience. My attitude has been the same as if I was swimming in ocean with the sharks. Figured I had equal chance of shark attack as bear attack. Then they all went paranoid about bear repellent and should we bring a gun and I started second guessing my casual acceptance of possible bears.

Britt, wolves and large cats don't concern me. I can read them (body language). Bears are foreign to me. Suspect would probably give similar cues as to intentions? --174.251.xxx.xx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by hubba huibba [CA]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 8:55 PM
Message:

This was in Truckee CA.

Forgot about some dinner roles I left in the car trunk.

Truckee bears understand cars. I left the car unlocked and the bear came by and just opened the door. Bear figures out the rolls are in the trunk and promptly started tearing out the back seat of the car.

Bear got the rolls. Bear didn't like the rolls and tore off my right side mirror on my car. Bear left the rolls.

Coulda been worse.

Remember, not a speck of food. You'll be fine.

--157.131.xxx.xx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by P.B. [MI]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 9:02 PM
Message:

They say a bear can smell food for over 13 miles so do not take snacks in your backpack.

Wear a flannel shirt and keep it unbuttoned. If you see a bear, bring the shirt up with your arms so it makes you look bigger than you are.

Stand your ground, do not make eye contact and NEVER turn your back on them and run. Try not to show fear. Hard to do, but animals have senses we only dream about. They can sense fear, easily.

Bears are predators and it is just second nature for a predator to chase anything that runs from them.

A sow is a bit different, especially if she has cubs. Again, never turn your back, just face them and step back slowly.

I would not recommend a gun. Unless you are a crack shot, you may wound it, in which case you would be facing an animal intent on killing you instead of running away.

We have had many bear encounters here. All have run from us, when encountered in the forest. They cross our yard, we mind our business and they mind theirs. When we hear of a bear attack, we wonder what the person did to tick them off. --67.22.x.xx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Oregon Woodsmoke [ID]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 9:03 PM
Message:

Barbara, unprovoked bear attacks are extremely rare. Don't get between a mama bear and her cubs and keep all food and toiletries far away from where you sleep.

Yes, toiletries. Bears can be attracted to the scents of deodorant and perfume and soap.

A big no-no is bacon grease. Bacon is what you want for breakfast when you are camping and bacon grease is the world's best bear attractant.

Much less danger than a shark attack. A hungry shark will try to eat you and bears aren't interested in eating you. They just want your breakfast pastries and your toothpaste. --76.178.xxx.xxx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Roy [AL]) Posted on: Jul 24, 2021 10:47 PM
Message:

Based on experience, I would only feel safe with .44 magnum under my pillow.

20 years ago, I took a 4 day /3 night river-rafting trip on one of the Class 4 rivers up there. At night, when you are trying to sleep inside your tent, you will hear sounds

from various animals that will make you nervous and make you wonder why you even came there. At 2:00a.m. in the morning, when you hear the sound of a 2,000 lb. Moose snorting just 100 feet from your tent, I would suggest you start praying that Moose does not come any closer. Same goes for bears too. --68.63.xxx.xxx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Small potatoes [NY]) Posted on: Jul 25, 2021 12:21 AM
Message:

If there are problem bears where you are headed then perhaps change your plans. My close family was in Colorado a couple of years ago when there was a bear problem. They were visiting friends in the area and it was a little dicey. I have bears at my cabin but I'm conscious not to grill good or leave trash. They walk past me to go downhill for easy pickings. Still I'm not sure I'd enjoy camping. It doesn't take much to catch their attention. --172.58.xx.xxx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by plenty [MO]) Posted on: Jul 25, 2021 8:09 AM
Message:

Read up on what BoyScouts do. Any recommends from the park rangers I would follow. The safest was is not to put yourself in the bear's territory. But since you are packed and going... you just have to run faster than one other. --172.58.xxx.xxx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by 6x6 [TN]) Posted on: Jul 25, 2021 11:05 AM
Message:

Poor Bears can't have peace and quiet.

The bears are not the problem as it is the humans invading there space. I would say that if you leave them alone then they will probably do the same. I personally would like to pet one but that is probably not a reasonable request as far as the bear is concerned. I wonder if I can pet one at the zoo?

Keep the food in sealed containers is what I have heard but you have to get it out to eat at some point.

--73.120.xx.xxx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Wilma [PA]) Posted on: Jul 25, 2021 2:26 PM
Message:

We've learned from OTHER campers some no-no's:

Never cook after dark.

Never cook bacon inside the camper.

Don't leave coolers on the picnic table.

Always chuck the trash in the secure campground receptacle before dark. Don't even keep a paper towel that got a little bit of grease on it to use to light your campfire later.

Don't leave even a candy bar wrapper in your car. (Well, that was our daughter, and only mice got in - but she then knew that she had a rust hole into her car's interior.)

We spent about a hour on the floor of our popup camper when a bear got into the trash at the next site, where a family of seven had forgotten to take their trash to the secure dumpster. We weren't too scared, just cautious and too far from the car to dash over to it. The family next door was terrified. The bear had a lovely dinner, then ambled back up the mountain at daybreak. --108.2.xx.xxx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Ltd [AZ]) Posted on: Jul 25, 2021 6:35 PM
Message:

LOL - Anything you need to know - ask a Landlord! :D

This is long, so go get a beverage...

I love telling bear stories, I can go all day. :D I have had many close bear encounters, maybe over a thousand. As a kid we split our time between the beach and the mountains. My mother was an administrator in Yosemite, and when I was about 11-15 and I spent part of the summers there. Our nightly entertainment was "helping" the rangers chase the bears out of the campgrounds. I met Todd Orr a few years ago, he's the forestry guy who was attacked twice by a grizzly near Bozeman and lived to tell the tale. Google his story and learn. His cousin is Mike Seeklander, the firearm instructor on the Outdoor channel TV show "Best Defense."

The past several summers (pre covid) my spouse and I have spent mostly in the Rockies. We've had a number of grizzly encounters, especially up in the Flathead Valley and around Glacier Pk. Also in western Wyoming. We have black bear here in AZ, quite a few actually. I encountered one in downtown Telluride 3 or 4 years ago in the middle of the day. Came out from between houses about 30 feet away. Took a look at us, we waved our arms in the air and yelled. It was not impressed, but turned and sauntered on down the sidewalk like it owned the place. We "sauntered" at a brisk pace the opposite direction! LOL

This is where a hiking buddy is invaluable. Remember, you don't gotta outrun the bear, just your buddy. ;)

Be "bear aware," but do not be paranoid about bears. People get attacked because they surprise the bear, or because they have something the bear wants (food). Some Grizzly are just bullys. Bear do not like to be surprised. Bears also get really upset when you throw rocks at them, so don't do it, unless you can swim. Ask me how I know this...

PLEASE DON'T SHOOT BEARS, you are in THEIR yard. A bear 50, 100, 500 feet away is not going to eat you... yet. More on guns in a minute.

BEAR SPRAY will suffice in 99.9% of encounters where other measures don't work.

Black bear: You overwhelmingly will encounter black bear. They are easily frightened and will generally run off with a little persuasion. Some urban bear are getting more acclimated to humans and are more insistent on getting their way, breaking into camps, cars, and even buildings. This is OUR fault. There are somewhere between 300-600,000 black bear in the US, overwhelmingly you will encounter them.

With a black bear, look at big as you can, wave your hands, yell, jump. DON'T charge it. If you have a group don't bunch up, spread out so the bear knows he's outnumbered. DON'T throw things at it. Loud noise will scare them off, usually. But in most states you can't just fire into the air anymore due to stupid laws.

Grizzly bear: Are another matter. They can, will and DO eat people! You are not the apex predator in the Rockies. They are. With black bear, moose and cougar close behind. There are only about 1,500 grizzly in the lower 48 and half of those are around Yellowstone. They are expanding their habitat, but the attrition rate is taking a toll as humans interact and decimate their population, again.

With a grizzly you DO NOT want to seem aggressive. Kneel down, talk quietly, don't move fast. SLOWLY BACK OFF while facing the bear. DO NOT run, ever. You will die!

And do this with a can of bear spray in one hand and a gun in the other!

More on this in Part Two...

--47.216.xx.xxx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Ltd [AZ]) Posted on: Jul 25, 2021 11:28 PM
Message:

PART TWO:

Sorry for the delay, we had a hellacious thunderstorm and lost internet. We got RAIN! Woot-woot! Thought the roof was going to blow off.

OK, let's talk defense against aggressive bears.

BEAR SPRAY is very effective. They say. I've never actually sprayed a bear. We were bluff charged in Yellowstone 4 or 5 years ago during a "bear jam." That's when stupid tourists stop along the road and create a traffic jam to watch a bear do what bears do in the woods. "Oh, how cute, let's get a selfie..."

This one was about 300 ft away and I guess it had "enough" and charged the whole bunch of us. It stopped about 150 feet away, probably because of the blood curdling screams of people scrambling for their cars. Or it may have realized there were about 20 cans of bear spray aimed at it. My pistol was safely stored in the car console across the road. LOL

Having never seen a big grizzly running full tilt boogie before let me say I was, impressed. And we made some protocol changes...

We carry the Counter Assault brand, which is the original, made in Kalispell, MT. It shoots "up to" 40 feet in a fog. It's a bit pricey at around $50 a can. If you are around Glacier or Yellowstone, you can sometimes score free cans from tourists flying home. They also rent them in the Natl Parks. I got some holsters at a police supply so we can wear on our belt or strap to a pack strap. The little pouches they come with are junk. If you need spray you probably need it PDQ, so you want it ready.

GUNS:

Again - PLEASE DON'T SHOOT BEARS!

I am not against lethal force, but it is seldom warranted. I usually just carry my 9mm, concealed.

After a couple of close encounters and talking to Todd, when in grizzly areas I started swapping out my regular ammo to hard cast "Buffalo Bore" ammo which is designed specifically for predatory game. If we are doing a planned hike in grizzly country we'll take our .44 magnum revolvers.

IMHO it really doesn't matter what you shoot a bear with, unless it's a Kodiak grizzly. There are reports of everything from .38's to big game guns being used successfully... and unsuccessfully.

And Finally - here is the problem with shooting at a bear - and why spray is better if it works. I'm a pretty good shot, I'm pretty well trained. I teach people to shoot. But a bear running full tilt boogie at you is an extremely difficult shot. You have a target moving 30 miles an hour, bouncing up and down about a foot each time, with a target area of 12-18" and if you miss you are dinner. Bon appetite. --47.216.xx.xxx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by 6x6 [TN]) Posted on: Jul 26, 2021 1:36 PM
Message:

LTD, you mentioned a good point that I hope everyone caught.

"This one was about 300 ft away and I guess it had "enough" and charged the whole bunch of us. It stopped about 150 feet away, probably because of the blood curdling screams of people scrambling for their cars."

To me, this says that, if you leave them alone then they will leave you alone. I think there are a lot of innocent bears and other animals that get killed or put down because of something a human caused.

--73.120.xx.xxx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Barbara [VA]) Posted on: Jul 26, 2021 9:03 PM
Message:

I may have come across as more paranoid than I am about it. Oddly I will be in the Bozeman Yellowstone area. We are launching at Livingston and travel to Bozeman? Not completely sure of exact itenary meeting up with everyone Wend. And will get complete plans then.

But, I knew this was where to go for info. And loving what Has been shared!

We aren't bringing guns but 1 couple is already there and they grabbed bear spray for all of us. It appears common sense, a cool head and we should be fine. I will be honest..part of me would love to see a drizzly while canoeing down the river. The other part is hoping not to have that moment. --174.251.xxx.xx




OT Montana/Bear concerns (by Lana [IN]) Posted on: Jul 28, 2021 10:33 PM
Message:

I am from Montana and the large animals there are a real concern. Rattlesnakes in my part of the badlands. The Montana/Dakotas are experiencing a massive drought and the animals are getting mighty desperate for food, so you might get into trouble. Do your best to be food careful and take lots of mosquito repellant as Montana mosquitoes take no prisoners. --216.23.xxx.xx





Reply:
Subject: RE: OT Montana/Bear concerns
Your Name:
Your State:

Message:
OT Montana/Bear concerns
Would you like to be notified via email when somebody replies to this thread?
If so, you must include your valid email address here. Do not add your address more than once per thread/subject. By entering your email address here, you agree to receive notification from Mrlandlord.com every time anyone replies to "this" thread. You will receive response notifications for up to one week following the original post. Your email address will not be visible to readers.
Email Address: